Critics of solar power have long contended that the technology is a hoax. The panels may appear to create clean energy but, when taking into account the fossil fuels burned to create electricity to manufacture the panels, they become quite dirty, opponents say. But a new study has found that solar panels make up for those emissions and then some over a 30-year lifetime. With advances made in the technology over the past four decades, solar panels now repay their energy consumption “multiple times,” according to a study published Tuesday in the journal Nature Communications. The study looked at data from solar panels going back to 1976 and determined that the total carbon costs of manufacturing solar panels, while high when the technology was still in nascent stages, was likely repaid in about 2011 when accounting for clean energy consumption displacing carbon dioxide. At the same time, renewable energy sources have become increasingly competitive compared to their fossil fuel counterparts. The strength of renewables remained visible even as crashing prices for oil, natural gas and coal were observed in the past couple of years.